Criminal Record Screening
A practical guide for consistent tenant selection.
Learn what criminal record screening can show, how SmartScreen searches criminal-history sources, and how landlords can review results as one part of a fair, documented tenant-screening process.

Criminal Record Screening for Tenant Selection
Criminal record screening helps landlords review reportable criminal-history information as part of a broader tenant-screening process. A useful report should make the search scope clear, match records carefully to the applicant, and give the landlord enough information to evaluate any returned result under written rental criteria.
SmartScreen’s current criminal screening product searches state and national criminal databases, the National Sex Offender Public Registry, and most-wanted databases. It also uses credit-bureau-strength record matching designed to reduce false positives and mismatched records. Coverage and reportable information vary by jurisdiction.
Key point: A criminal report should be one part of the applicant file, not an automatic pass-or-fail rule. Review the actual record, apply the same written process to similarly situated applicants, and check the rules where the rental property is located.
Why Criminal Record Screening Matters
Criminal history can provide information that is not available in a credit or eviction report. Used carefully, it can help a landlord understand potential safety or property-risk concerns while keeping the decision focused on relevant, documented information.
Review relevant risk
Look at the nature of any returned record, its status, timing, and relevance to the tenancy rather than relying only on a name match.
Reduce mismatches
Applicant matching matters because similar names can create false positives. Review identifying details before relying on a returned record.
Use the full applicant file
Criminal history does not show payment behavior, eviction history, or income. Those questions require separate screening information.
Document the decision
Written criteria and consistent notes can help show that the same screening process was applied to each applicant.
What SmartScreen Searches
According to SmartScreen’s current Criminal Report page, the criminal screening process includes these core search components:
- State and national criminal database searches across available reportable records.
- National Sex Offender Public Registry search as a separate registry component.
- Most-wanted database searches included in the criminal-screening product.
- Credit-bureau-strength record matching designed to reduce false positives and mismatched records.
Criminal-record availability is affected by federal, state, and local law. Some jurisdictions restrict what may be returned or used in housing decisions, so landlords should review the current product coverage and the law that applies to the rental property.
How Landlords Can Review Criminal Screening Results
- Start with written criteria. Decide in advance how criminal-history information will be reviewed and keep the criteria relevant to the rental decision.
- Confirm the applicant and search scope. Make sure the returned record belongs to the applicant and understand what sources or jurisdictions were searched.
- Review the actual record details. Look at disposition, timing, severity, and any other reportable information rather than making a decision from a headline or name match.
- Check state and local restrictions. Some jurisdictions limit when criminal history may be requested, what may be considered, or what notice must be provided.
- Compare the full screening file. Review criminal history alongside credit, eviction, income, rental history, and other lawful criteria.
- Document the final decision. Keep notes showing which written criteria were applied and why the decision was reached.
FCRA and Fair Housing Considerations
Tenant background checks supplied by a consumer reporting agency are consumer reports under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. The FTC states that landlords must have a permissible housing purpose before obtaining a report and must provide an adverse-action notice if information in a consumer report contributes to an unfavorable rental decision.
The FTC also cautions that a blanket policy refusing to rent to anyone with a criminal record may violate the Fair Housing Act. Federal fair-housing law remains in effect, and state or local rules may impose additional criminal-screening requirements.
Compliance reminder: Screening rules vary significantly by location. Check current requirements for the property’s jurisdiction before setting criminal-history criteria, and do not rely on an old policy or guidance document as a substitute for current law.
Use Criminal Records as Part of Complete Tenant Screening
Each screening report answers a different question. Criminal screening provides criminal-history information, while credit, eviction, income, and ResidentScore provide separate views of rental risk and applicant qualifications.
Credit Report
Review payment history, debt load, collections, and ResidentScore.
Eviction Report
Review eviction-related court history that may not appear on a standard credit report.
Income Insights
Use income information as part of the applicant’s ability-to-pay review.
ResidentScore
Review a rental-focused risk score alongside the underlying screening information.
Related SmartScreen Resources
Frequently Asked Questions
What is criminal record screening?
Criminal record screening is the review of reportable criminal-history and registry information returned by the sources included in a tenant screening report. It is one component of a broader rental application review.
What does SmartScreen search?
SmartScreen’s current criminal report searches state and national criminal databases, the National Sex Offender Public Registry, and most-wanted databases, with credit-bureau-strength record matching designed to reduce mismatches.
Can a landlord automatically deny anyone with a criminal record?
A blanket rule can create legal risk. The FTC cautions that a policy refusing to rent to anyone with a criminal record may violate the Fair Housing Act. Landlords should also check applicable state and local restrictions.
Is criminal screening enough by itself?
No. Criminal history does not show the applicant’s credit behavior, eviction history, income, or complete rental history. Review the full lawful screening file before making a decision.
What happens if a criminal report contributes to a denial?
If a consumer report contributes in whole or in part to an unfavorable rental decision, the FCRA requires an adverse-action notice that gives the applicant information about the reporting agency and their dispute rights.
Sources & Related Guidance
- SmartScreen — Tenant Criminal Report
- SmartScreen — Sample Criminal Report
- Federal Trade Commission — Using Consumer Reports: What Landlords Need to Know
- HUD — Fair Housing Rights and Obligations
Screen applicants with SmartScreen.
Review criminal, credit, eviction, income, and ResidentScore information through one online tenant-screening workflow.