SmartScreen Landlord Screening Guide

Can I Use a Background Check Instead of a Credit Report?

Understand when each rental screening report helps—and why they are not interchangeable.

Can you use a background check instead of a credit report? Often yes, but background and credit reports cover different information. Learn which records they contain, how they fit your leasing policy, and what the FCRA requires.

Compare credit, criminal and eviction screening, review SmartScreen package options, and learn a practical approach to fair applicant decisions.

Updated November 2026Tenant ScreeningCredit vs. BackgroundFCRA & Fair Housing
Property professionals comparing credit report and background check documents in a bright office
Immediate AccessTenant ScreeningTransUnion CreditResidentScoreCriminal ReportsEviction ReportsRenter Pay Option

Can I Use a Background Check Instead of a Credit Report?

Yes. In many rental situations, a landlord can choose a tenant background check without purchasing a separate credit report. Federal law does not require every landlord to obtain both. But the reports answer different questions, and state, local or housing-program rules may limit screening choices.

A criminal or eviction report may reveal available court records. A credit report may show reported payment history, outstanding accounts and collections. Neither automatically proves income, rental behavior or future payment reliability.

Quick answer: Choose reports based on written, lawful screening criteria. Know what each report includes, verify important matches and follow the FCRA and Fair Housing requirements for any consumer report you use.

Background Check vs. Credit Report: What Is the Difference?

The term background check is broad. Some tenant-screening background checks include credit history; others focus only on criminal or eviction records. Always review the product’s actual contents rather than relying on its name.

Credit report

Typically includes reported credit accounts, payment patterns, balances and certain collections. A rental-focused score may accompany the report.

Criminal background report

Contains available reportable criminal records subject to coverage, accuracy and legal restrictions. A hit is not proof of identity or guilt.

Eviction report

May show available housing court filings and outcomes. A filing, dismissal and judgment are distinct events.

Rental references and income

Usually require separate applicant documents or verification. These are not automatically confirmed by a criminal or eviction database.

At-a-Glance Report Comparison

InformationCredit reportCriminal / eviction reports
Reported debt paymentsOftenGenerally not
Credit-based rental scoreMay be includedGenerally not
Criminal court recordsGenerally notMay be included
Eviction court casesNot a substitute for an eviction reportMay be included in an eviction search
Verified employment or wagesNoNot by default
Former landlord feedbackNo, unless separately reported data appliesRequires a separate reference process

Results vary by vendor and product. A bundled report may contain several of these components. Never assume every public record or prior rent payment is reported.

What Does a Rental Credit Report Reveal?

A credit report can show payment history for reported accounts, credit utilization, amounts owed and certain collection accounts. Some rental products include a specialized score such as TransUnion ResidentScore (350–850).

Credit files can be incomplete, and an applicant may have limited credit history. Most ordinary rent payments do not appear unless they have been reported. A score is one input, not an automatic reason to accept or reject someone.

For more detail, read the rental credit report guide and ResidentScore factors.

What Does a Tenant Background Check Reveal?

Depending on the package, a tenant background check can provide available criminal records, eviction history or both. Results can be limited by jurisdiction, database coverage, case sealing, reporting rules and identity mismatches.

An arrest is not a conviction. Likewise, an eviction filing is not necessarily a judgment or evidence that a tenant was removed. Review disposition and matching information before relying on a record.

See eviction reports and Fair Housing screening guidance.

When Might a Landlord Use One Report or Both?

The right screening mix depends on the property, the nature of the tenancy and lawful, disclosed requirements. Neither report is legally mandatory in every private rental situation.

Background only

May fit a policy that does not review credit, if permitted by law. It leaves credit payment information unreviewed.

Credit only

May fit a policy focused on reported financial accounts. It does not replace dedicated court searches.

Combined reports

Offer distinct categories of information in one application workflow, subject to lawful screening criteria and cost.

A combined product is a choice, not a guarantee against nonpayment or tenancy problems. Use a written policy and avoid requesting data you do not need.

Can Either Report Verify Income or Employment?

Not by itself. A credit report can show certain financial accounts but does not confirm a current paycheck. Criminal and eviction reports do not verify a current employer either.

SmartScreen’s Income Insights is an income-plausibility assessment. It is not direct payroll, salary or employer verification. For direct verification, use appropriate employer contact, authorized payroll records or other lawful documentation.

Learn more about verifying employment during tenant screening.

A Seven-Step Tenant Screening Process

1. Establish criteria

Decide which report types you need before accepting applications.

2. Disclose the process

Provide lawful application instructions and any required fee or authorization information.

3. Confirm purpose

Use the consumer reporting agency’s housing-purpose and authorization workflow.

4. Obtain reports

Request only the components covered by your written criteria.

5. Review matches

Check relevant identities, case outcomes and material discrepancies.

6. Verify separately

Check rental references and income when the policy requires them.

7. Document and notify: Apply lawful, consistent standards. When a consumer report contributes to adverse action, provide the required notice.

FCRA Requirements for Credit and Background Reports

The FTC explains that tenant credit, criminal, eviction and bundled screening reports provided by consumer reporting agencies can all be consumer reports under the FCRA. Landlords need a permissible housing purpose and must comply with the reporting agency’s conditions. The federal housing-use rule does not universally require the employment-specific standalone disclosure or fixed pre-adverse-action waiting period sometimes described online.

If consumer report information contributes to denial, a higher deposit, a guarantor requirement or other unfavorable housing terms, an adverse-action notice is generally required. The notice identifies the agency, explains the applicant’s rights and provides the required information. Additional disclosures apply when a credit score is used in the adverse action.

Read the FTC’s landlord consumer-report guidance. Local law or provider agreements may impose further authorization, notification or timing requirements.

Fair Housing and Record Accuracy

Apply lawful standards consistently and comply with the Fair Housing Act. Avoid screening practices that discriminate on protected grounds, including policies involving criminal history that may violate applicable guidance or law.

Check whether cases actually belong to the applicant, distinguish arrests from convictions, review dismissed eviction cases accurately, and handle relevant disputes. State and local rules can restrict which records may be considered or reported.

See Tenant Discrimination Avoidance and HUD’s Fair Housing overview.

Applicant Privacy and the Apply Now Link

Use a secure application and avoid asking applicants to email Social Security numbers or full credit reports. SmartScreen’s TransUnion workflow lets applicants supply sensitive identifying details directly.

The Apply Now Link can be shared from a landlord website or listing where outside application links are permitted. It can collect reported prior-landlord and employment history for follow-up; those references still require separate verification.

Limit access to screening results and dispose of report information securely according to law and applicable agreements.

SmartScreen Packages: Credit and Background Options

SmartScreen’s published Basic, Plus, Deluxe and Premium packages all include a TransUnion credit report with ResidentScore. They are not standalone background-only products. Choose the combination that aligns with the screening criteria.

Basic — $36

Credit, ResidentScore and nationwide criminal report.

Plus — $39

Credit, ResidentScore and Income Insights.

Deluxe — $41

Credit, ResidentScore and nationwide eviction report.

Premium — $45

Credit, ResidentScore, nationwide criminal, nationwide eviction and Income Insights.

Registration is free with no setup fees or monthly minimums. Landlord-pay and renter-pay options are available where allowed. See current SmartScreen pricing before ordering.

Background Check vs. Credit Report: Landlord Checklist

  • Write lawful, property-specific selection criteria before reviewing applicants.
  • Identify exactly which reports the screening provider supplies.
  • Use a permissible housing purpose and required authorization process.
  • Compare credit information separately from court-record findings.
  • Verify identity matches and case dispositions.
  • Check income and rental references separately when needed.
  • Apply Fair Housing standards, accommodations and local restrictions.
  • Give required adverse-action notices when report data contributes to unfavorable action.
  • Protect and dispose of consumer report information securely.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I legally use only a background check without credit?

Often yes, where allowed by state and local law and consistent with your lawful policy. Federal law does not universally require every landlord to purchase both report types.

Is a tenant background check the same as a credit check?

Not necessarily. Background check is a broad term; some products include credit while others cover criminal or eviction records only.

Does a clean criminal report mean an applicant has good credit?

No. Criminal and credit information come from different sources and serve different purposes.

Can a credit report show prior evictions?

Do not treat a credit report as a complete eviction-court search. A dedicated eviction report covers a different source of information.

Does SmartScreen sell a background-only package?

The four published packages on SmartScreen’s pricing page each include credit and ResidentScore. Contact the company to ask about any separately available service.

Do I need written consent before running tenant reports?

Landlords need a permissible purpose and must follow provider and applicable state/local authorization requirements. The FCRA’s employment-only standalone disclosure rule should not be misapplied to every housing report.

What if a consumer report influenced a denial?

An FCRA adverse-action notice is generally required even when report information was only one contributing factor.

Does Income Insights verify the applicant’s salary?

No. It is a plausibility assessment, not direct payroll or employer verification.

Related Tenant Screening Resources

Credit Reports

Understand reported credit data and ResidentScore. Rental credit report guide.

Property Background Checks

Review available court-record screening. Rental background check guide.

For Landlords

Learn the SmartScreen application process. Landlord screening information.

Common Questions

See published report and account information. SmartScreen FAQs.

Updated November 2026. Educational material, not legal advice. Report availability and screening rules vary by location.

Compare SmartScreen Tenant Screening Packages

Use credit and available background reports as part of a consistent, lawful applicant screening process.

Create a Free Account